Unveiling the Mediating Role of Environmental Awareness: A Study on Gamified Rewards
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.13052/jmm1550-4646.2112Keywords:
Gamified reward, Environmental Awareness, Environmental Motivation, S-O-R model, Ant ForestAbstract
Gamification is part of modern mobile applications that serves as a design element. The reward element in gamification has a positive role in stimulating the behavioural intentions of the users. Having said that, plenty of virtual and physical gamified rewards can be found in Ant Forest – a popular large-scale mobile pro-environmental application in China. In particular, Ant Forest promotes environmental awareness and motivation among its players attributable to its excellent application of gamified rewards to pro-environmental behaviour of afforestation. This study applied the Stimuli-Organism-Response (S-O-R) Model to construct a theoretical framework with the variables of gamified rewards, environmental awareness and motivation, and specifically focused on the mediating effect of environmental awareness. By using the stratified proportional sampling technique, 621 Ant Forest users from six cities in China were surveyed to determine the role of users’ environmental awareness using the Partial Least Square-Structural Equation Modelling (PLS-SEM) approach. The study outcomes disclosed that gamified rewards in Ant Forest had a positive and strong impact on the environmental awareness of the users, while environmental awareness displayed a positive and strong impact on the environmental motivation of the users. Nonetheless, gamified rewards did not directly influence environmental motivation. Given the key finding that environmental awareness exhibited a strong mediation effect, it emerged as a key element that linked gamified rewards with environmental motivation among users. Imminently, the application scope of the S-O-R Model is expanded in this study. In doing so, the significance of environmental awareness among users is highlighted for the relationship between gamified reward and environmental motivation. In addition, this study provides feasible suggestions for developers of environmental applications to design effective gamification strategies by reasonably stimulating users’ environmental awareness.
Downloads
References
S. Deterding, D. Dixon, R. Khaled, L. Nacke, ‘From game design elements to gamefulness: defining “gamification”’, In Proceedings of the 15th international academic MindTrek conference: Envisioning future media environments, (pp. 9–15), 2011.
J. Hamari, J. Koivisto, H. Sarsa, ‘Does gamification work? A literature review of empirical studies on gamification’, In 2014 47th Hawaii international conference on system sciences, (pp. 3025–3034). IEEE, 2014.
M. Garcia-Iruela, R. Hijón-Neira, C. Connolly, ‘Analysis of three methodological approaches in the use of gamification in vocational training’, Information, 12(8), 300, 2021.
L. Whittaker, R. Russell-Bennett, R. Mulcahy, ‘Reward-based or meaningful gaming? A field study on game mechanics and serious games for sustainability’, Psychology & Marketing, 38(6), 981–1000, 2021.
Á. Tóth, E. Lógó, ‘The effect of gamification in sport applications’, In 9th IEEE International Conference on Cognitive Infocommunications (CogInfoCom), (pp. 069–074), IEEE, 2018.
A. Suh, C. Wagner, ‘How gamification of an enterprise collaboration system increases knowledge contribution: an affordance approach’, Journal of Knowledge Management, 21(2), 416–431, 2017.
J. Hamari, ‘Do badges increase user activity? A field experiment on the effects of gamification’, Computers in human behavior, 71, 469–478, 2017.
T. Ouariachi, C. Y. Li, W. J. Elving, ‘Gamification approaches for education and engagement on pro-environmental behaviors: Searching for best practices’, Sustainability, 12(11), 4565, 2020.
C. Rodosthenous, E. Mavrotheris, W. Greller, B. Tabuenca, ‘Creating environmental awareness in education through IoT and gamification’ In International Conference on Interactive Collaborative Learning, (pp. 657–668), Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2022.
K. Koroleva, J. Novak, ‘How to engage with sustainability issues we rarely experience? A gamification model for collective awareness platforms in water-related sustainability’, Sustainability, 12(2), 712, 2020.
D. Thor, P. Karlsudd, ‘Teaching and fostering an active environmental awareness design, validation and planning for action-oriented environmental education’, Sustainability, 12(8), 3209, 2020.
D. Böhm, B. Dorland, R. Herzog, R. B. Kap, T. S. Langendam, A. Popa, M. Bueno, R. Bidarra, ‘How can you save the world? Empowering sustainable diet change with a serious game’, In 2021 IEEE conference on games (CoG), (pp. 1–7). IEEE, 2021.
S. Nicholson, ‘A recipe for meaningful gamification. In Gamification in education and business’, (pp. 1–20). Springer, Cham. Switzerland, 2015.
K. Robson, K. Plangger, J. H. Kietzmann, I. McCarthy, L. Pitt, ‘Is it all a game? Understanding the principles of gamification’, Business horizons, 58(4), 411–420, 2015.
D. Wemyss, F. Cellina, E. Lobsiger-Kägi, V. De Luca, R. Castri, ‘Does it last? Long-term impacts of an app-based behavior change intervention on household electricity savings in Switzerland’, Energy Research & Social Science, 47, 16–27, 2019.
M. M. van Dooren, V. T. Visch, R. Spijkerman, ‘The Design and Application of Game Rewards in Youth Addiction Care’, Information, 10(4), 126, 2019.
D. Liu, H. Du, F. Southworth, S. Ma, ‘The influence of social-psychological factors on the intention to choose low-carbon travel modes in Tianjin, China’, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 105, 42–53, 2017.
D. Oppong-Tawiah, J. Webster, S. Staples, A. F. Cameron, A. O. de Guinea, T. Y. Hung, ‘Developing a gamified mobile application to encourage sustainable energy use in the office’, Journal of Business Research, 106, 388–405, 2020.
X. Wang, X. Yao, ‘Fueling pro-environmental behaviors with gamification design: identifying key elements in ant forest with the kano model’, Sustainability, 12(6), 2213, 2020.
Y. Bai, Y. Liu, ‘An exploration of residents’ low-carbon awareness and behavior in Tianjin, China’, Energy Policy, 61, 1261–1270, 2013.
H. Du, D. Liu, B. K. Sovacool, Y. Wang, S. Ma, R. Y. M. Li, ‘Who buys New Energy Vehicles in China? Assessing social-psychological predictors of purchasing awareness, intention, and policy’, Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, 58, 56–69, 2018.
M. Ling, L. Xu, ‘How and when financial incentives crowd out pro-environmental motivation: A longitudinal quasi-experimental study’, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 78, 101715, 2021.
S. Xu, C. Chu, Y. Zhang, D. Ye, Y. Wang, M. Ju, ‘Entangled stakeholder roles and perceptions of sustainable consumption: An evaluation of sustainable consumption practices in Tianjin, China’, Journal of environmental management, 223, 841–848, 2018.
X. Gong, J. Zhang, H. Zhang, M. Cheng, F., Wang, N. Yu, ‘Internet use encourages pro-environmental behavior: Evidence from China’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 256, 120725, 2020.
M. Ashfaq, Q. Zhang, A. U. Zafar, M. Malik, A. Waheed, ‘Understanding Ant Forest continuance: effects of user experience, personal attributes and motivational factors’, Industrial Management & Data Systems, 122(2), 471–498, 2021.
Z. Yang, X. Kong, J. Sun, Y. Zhang, ‘Switching to green lifestyles: Behavior change of ant forest users’, International journal of environmental research and public health, 15(9), 1819, 2018.
Y. Chen, D. Cai, ‘Ant Forest through the haze: a case study of gamified participatory pro-environmental communication in China’, Multidisciplinary Scientific Journal, 2(4), 30, 2019.
L. Mi, T. Xu, Y. Sun, J. Zhao, T. Lv, X. Gan, K. Shang, L. Qiao, ‘Playing Ant Forest to promote online green behavior: A new perspective on uses and gratifications. Journal of environmental management’, 278, 111544, 2021.
N. Xiong, P. Ren, B. Sun, S. He, L. Jiang, H. Cui, ‘Influence of incentive mechanism and fit degree on user’s environmental behavior – Taking Alipay “Ant Forest” in China as an example’, Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 1033553, 2022.
B. Zhang, X. Hu, M. Gu, ‘Promote pro-environmental behaviour through social media: An empirical study based on Ant Forest’, Environmental Science & Policy, 137, 216–227, 2022.
Chen, Y. Feng, J. Sun, J. Yan, ‘Motivation Analysis of Online Green Users: Evidence from Chinese “Ant Forest”’, Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 1335, 2020.
B. D. Douglas, M. Brauer, ‘Gamification to prevent climate change: A review of games and apps for sustainability’, Current opinion in psychology, 42, 89–94, 2021.
M. Troncota, ‘European Green Deal and the New Policy Goals in Transport and Mobility-How Gamification Can Influence Pro-Environmental Behaviour for Cutting Carbon Emissions in the EU’, Europolity-Continuity and Change in European Governance, 14(2), 89–130, 2020.
L. Aguiar-Castillo, A. Clavijo-Rodriguez, P. De Saa-Perez, R. Perez-Jimenez, ‘Gamification as an approach to promote tourist recycling behavior’, Sustainability, 11(8), 2201, 2019.
M. T. Goi, V. Kalidas, M. Zeeshan, ‘Comparison of stimulus-organism-response framework between international and local retailer’, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 130, 461–468, 2014.
V. A. Vieira, ‘Stimuli-organism-response framework: A meta-analytic review in the store environment’, Journal of Business research, 66(9), 1420–1426, 2013.
R. Gatautis, E. Vitkauskaite, A. Gadeikiene, Z. Piligrimiene, ‘Gamification as a mean of driving online consumer behaviour: SOR model perspective’, Engineering Economics, 27(1), 90–97, 2016.
A. Mehrabian, J. A. Russell, ‘An approach to environmental psychology’, (pp. 795–796), the MIT Press, USA, 1974.
J. Guo, Y. Li, Y. Xu, K. Zeng, ‘How live streaming features impact consumers’ purchase intention in the context of cross-border E-commerce? A research based on SOR theory’, Frontiers in psychology, 12, 767876, 2021.
N. J. Thomas, R. Baral, ‘Mechanism of gamification: Role of flow in the behavioral and emotional pathways of engagement in management education’, The International Journal of Management Education, 21(1), 100718, 2023.
J. Hwang, L. Choi, ‘Having fun while receiving rewards? Exploration of gamification in loyalty programs for consumer loyalty’ Journal of Business Research, 106, 365–376, 2020.
P. Tak, M. Gupta, ‘Examining travel mobile app attributes and its impact on consumer engagement: An application of SOR framework’, Journal of Internet Commerce, 20(3), 293–318, 2021.
R. Alebaikan, H. Alajlan, A. Almassaad, N. Alshamri, Y. Bain, ‘Experiences of Middle School Programming in an Online Learning Environment’, Behavioral Sciences, 12, 466, 2022.
V. J. Sotos-Martínez, J. Tortosa-Martínez, S. Baena-Morales, A. Ferriz-Valero, ‘Boosting Student’s Motivation through Gamification in Physical Education’, Behavioral Sciences, 13, 165, 2023.
E. Haque, T. Sungsuwan, S. Sanglimsuwan, ‘Can social media be a tool for increasing tourists’ environmentally responsible behavior?’ Geo Journal of Tourism and Geosites, 38(4), 1211–1222, 2021.
Y. Du, X. Wang, D. Brombal, A. Moriggi, A. Sharpley, S. Pang, ‘Changes in environmental awareness and its connection to local environmental management in water conservation zones: the case of Beijing, China’, Sustainability, 10(6), 2087, 2018.
N. S. Mei, C. W. Wai, R. Ahamad, ‘Environmental awareness and behaviour index for Malaysia’, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 222, 668–675, 2016.
M. L. Umuhire, Q. Fang, ‘Method and application of ocean environmental awareness measurement: Lessons learnt from university students of China’, Marine pollution bulletin, 102(2), 289–294, 2016.
W. Handayani, R. R. Ariescy, F. A. Cahya, S. I. Yusnindi, D. A. Sulistyo, ‘Literature Review: Environmental Awareness and Pro-Environmental Behavior’, In 5th International Seminar of Research Month 2020, (pp. 170–173), NST Proceedings, 2021.
W. Wang, W. Wu, J. Luo, J. Lu, ‘Information technology usage, motivation, and intention: a case of Chinese urban senior outbound travelers in the Yangtze River Delta region’, Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, 22(1), 99–115, 2017.
J. Geng, R. Long, H. Chen, T. Yue, W. Li, Q. Li, ‘Exploring multiple motivations on urban residents’ travel mode choices: An empirical study from Jiangsu province in China’, Sustainability, 9(1), 136, 2017.
Z. Li, J. Xue, R. Li, H. Chen, T. Wang, ‘Environmentally specific transformational leadership and employee’s pro-environmental behavior: the mediating roles of environmental passion and autonomous motivation’, Frontiers in psychology, 11, 1408, 2020.
J. Steinhorst, C. A. Klöckner, ‘Effects of monetary versus environmental information framing: Implications for long-term pro-environmental behavior and intrinsic motivation’, Environment and Behavior, 50(9), 997–1031, 2018.
L. H. Shih, Y. C. Jheng, ‘Selecting persuasive strategies and game design elements for encouraging energy saving behavior’, Sustainability, 9(7), 1281, 2017.
Antonache, A.L.; Rosner, D.; Cociorba, A. A Gamification Based Approach for Users’ Behavior Change towards Power Consumption Reduction. eLearning & Software for Education. 2020, 1, 19–25, 2020.
A. J. Shie, Y. Y. Dai, M. X. Shen, L. Tian, M. Yang, W. W. Luo, Y. J. Wu, Z. H. Su, ‘Diamond model of green commitment and low-carbon travel motivation, constraint, and intention’, International journal of environmental research and public health, 19(14), 8454, 2022.
Raeisi, M. Bijani, M. Chizari, ‘The mediating role of environmental emotions in transition from knowledge to sustainable use of groundwater resources in Iran’s agriculture’, International Soil and Water Conservation Research, 6(2), 143–152, 2018.
H. Taljaard, N. C. Sonnenberg, B. M. Jacobs, ‘Factors motivating male consumers’ eco-friendly apparel acquisition in the South African emerging market’, International journal of consumer studies, 42(5), 461–468, 2018.
Zeng, Z.; Tang, J.; Wang, T. Motivation mechanism of gamification in crowdsourcing projects. International Journal of Crowd Science, 1(1), 71–82, 2017.
D. Kotsopoulos, C. Bardaki, P. G. Thanasis, S. Lounis, K. Pramatari, ‘Gamification at Work: Employee Motivations to Participate and Preference for Energy Conservation’, In Proceedings of the 12th Mediterranean Conference on Information Systems (MCIS), Corfu, Greece. 2018, 19, 2018.
M. M. Michaelsen, T. Esch, ‘Motivation and reward mechanisms in health behavior change processes’, Brain research, 1757, 147309, 2021.
V. U. Ludwig, K. W. Brown, J. A. Brewer, ‘Self-regulation without force: Can awareness leverage reward to drive behavior change?’ Perspectives on Psychological Science, 15(6), 1382–1399, 2020.
L. Morganti, F. Pallavicini, E. Cadel, A. Candelieri, F. Archetti, F. Mantovani, ‘Gaming for Earth: Serious games and gamification to engage consumers in pro-environmental behaviours for energy efficiency’, Energy Research & Social Science, 29, 95–102, 2017.
Y. Zhang, S. Xiao, G. Zhou, ‘User continuance of a green behavior mobile application in China: An empirical study of Ant Forest’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 242, 118497, 2020.
N. Wang, W. Hou, X. Zhang, Z. Wang, L. Yang, ‘Quantifying the effects of the ‘Internet plus Ecology’ framework on carbon sink in the digital age: a representative study of Ant Forest in China’, Environmental Research Letters, 17(12), 124005, 2022.
V. Benny, ‘The Impact of Behavioral Factors Influences on Individual Investors in Stock Market Investment’, International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews, 5(4), 119–126, 2018.
P. Leavy, ‘Research design: Quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, arts-based, and community-based participatory research approaches’, Guilford Publications, New York, USA, 2022.
U. Joshi, S. Poudyal, S. Hekka, N. Lawaju, M. Pradhan, ‘Maximum mouth opening of children in Newari population of Bhaktapur’, Journal of Chitwan Medical College, 11(2), 88–91, 2021.
L. Xiao, L. Hou, ‘Effect of glucosamine capsule on cartilage metabolism-related genes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients with knee osteoarthritis’, Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research, 24(31), 5007, 2020.
P. Leavy, (Ed.), Handbook of arts-based research, Guilford Publications, 2017.
U. Sekaran, R. Bougie, ‘Research methods for business: A skill building approach’, John Wiley & Sons, Wiley, USA, 2017.
T. Guan, K. Meng, W. Liu, L. Xue, ‘Public attitudes toward sustainable development goals: Evidence from five Chinese cities’, Sustainability, 11(20), 5793, 2019.
Government Data. List of Chinese cities. Retrieved from http://data.acmr.com.cn/member/city/city_md.asp, 2022.
State Council. Circular of the State Council on Adjusting the Criteria for the Classification of City Sizes. Retrieved from https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/ztzl/xxczhjs/ghzc/201605/t20160509_971910.html?code=&state=123, 2014.
S. E. Brown, L. Scobbie, L. Worrall, M. C. Brady, ‘A multinational online survey of the goal setting practice of rehabilitation staff with stroke survivors with aphasia’, Aphasiology, 1–25, 2022.
A. Phakiti, ‘Likert-type Scale Construction’, In the Routledge handbook of second language acquisition and language testing, (pp. 102–114), Routledge, 2020.
L. Zhang, Z. Shao, X. Li, Y. Feng, ‘Gamification and online impulse buying: The moderating effect of gender and age’, Inter-national Journal of Information Management, 61, 102267, 2021.
P. R. Lima, A. A. M. Pereira, G. D. L. D. Chaves, A. P. Meneguelo, ‘Environmental awareness and public perception on carbon capture and storage (CCS) in Brazil’, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 111, 103467, 2021.
X. Liu, Y. He, H. Fu, B. Chen, M. Wang, Z. Wang, ‘How environmental protection motivation influences on residents’ recycled water reuse behaviors: a case study in Xi’an city’, Water, 10(9), 1282, 2018.
M. V. Paulin, S. M. Caney, K. L. Cosford, ‘Online survey to determine client perceptions of feline chronic lower airway disease management: response to therapy, side effects and challenges encountered’, Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 0(0), 1098612X211070988, 2022.
Z. F. Su, Y. Z. Fu, M. Y. Chen, ‘Impacts of a Gender Ratio Change on China’s Wage Income Distributions’, Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, 58(7), 2066–2078, 2022.
W. J. Tu, X. Zeng, Q. Liu, ‘Aging tsunami coming: the main finding from China’s seventh national population census’, Aging clinical and experimental research, 34, 1159–1163, 2021.
J. H. Cheah, F. Magno, F. Cassia, ‘Reviewing the SmartPLS 4 software: the latest features and enhancements’, Journal of Marketing Analytics, 12, 97–107, 2024.
J. F. Hair, J. J. Risher, M. Sarstedt, C. M. Ringle, ‘When to use and how to report the results of PLS-SEM’, European business review, 31(1), 2–24, 2019.
M. I. Nasution, M. Fahmi, M. A. Prayogi, ‘The Quality of Small and Medium Enterprises Performance Using the Structural Equation Model-Part Least Square (SEM-PLS)’, In Journal of Physics: Conference Series, (Vol. 1477, No. 5, p. 052052), IOP Publishing, 2020.
A. Afthanorhan, P. L. Ghazali, N. Rashid, ‘Discriminant validity: a comparison of CBSEM and consistent PLS using Fornell & Larcker and HTMT approaches’, In Journal of Physics: Conference Series, (Vol. 1874, No. 1, p. 012085), IOP Publishing, 2021.
J. F. Hair Jr, G. T. M. Hult, C. M. Ringle, M. Sarstedt, N. P. Danks, S. Ray, ‘Partial least squares structural equation odelling (PLS-SEM) using R: A workbook’, (pp. 78–80). Springer Nature, 2021.
M. Sarstedt, C. M. Ringle, J. F. Hair, ‘Partial least squares structural equation odelling’, In Handbook of market research, (pp. 587-632), Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2021.
J. Cohen, ‘Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2nd
Edition’, Routledge, New York, 2013.
J. F. Hair Jr, M. Sarstedt, C. M. Ringle, S. P. Gudergan, ‘Advanced issues in partial least squares structural equation modelling’, SAGE Publications, London, UK, 2017.
L. Varela-Candamio, I. Novo-Corti, M. T. García-Álvarez, ‘The importance of environmental education in the determinants of green behavior: A meta-analysis approach’, Journal of cleaner production, 170, 1565–1578, 2018.
E. Yafi, S. Tehseen, S. A. Haider, ‘Impact of green training on environmental performance through mediating role of competencies and motivation’, Sustainability, 13(10), 5624, 2021.
M. Karpudewan, N. S. Mohd Ali Khan, ‘Experiential-based climate change education: Fostering students’ knowledge and motivation towards the environment’, International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 26(3), 207–222, 2017.
Y. Sun, J. Xing, ‘The Impact of Gamification Motivation on Green Consumption Behavior – An Empirical Study Based on Ant Forest’, Sustainability, 15(1), 512, 2023.
M. Ashfaq, Q. Zhang, A. U. Zafar, M. Malik, A. Waheed, ‘Understanding Ant Forest continuance: effects of user experience, personal attributes and motivational factors’, Industrial Management & Data Systems, 122(2), 471–498, 2021.
S. Wang, M. H. Li, M. Ibrahiem, ‘Motivations Influencing Alipay Users to Participate in the Ant Forest Campaign: An Empirical Study’, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(24), 17034, 2022.
A. Shafiei, H. Maleksaeidi, ‘Pro-environmental behavior of university students: Application of protection motivation theory’, Global Ecology and Conservation, 22, e00908, 2020.
X. Chen, L. Chen, D. Wu, ‘Factors that influence employees’ security policy compliance: an awareness-motivation-capability perspective’, Journal of Computer Information Systems, 58(4), 312–324, 2018.
S. Kasten, L. van Osch, M. Candel, H. de Vries, ‘The influence of pre-motivational factors on behavior via motivational factors: a test of the I-Change model’, BMC psychology, 7, 1–12, 2019.
W. Li, T. A. Bhutto, W. Xuhui, Q. Maitlo, A. U. Zafar, N. A. Bhutto, ‘Unlocking employees’ green creativity: The effects of green transformational leadership, green intrinsic, and extrinsic motivation’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 255, 120229, 2020.
M. Yee, T. S. Braver, ‘Interactions of motivation and cognitive control’, Current opinion in behavioral sciences, 19, 83–90, 2018.
B. Zhu, S. Kowatthanakul, P. Satanasavapak, ‘Generation Y consumer online repurchase intention in Bangkok: Based on Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) model’, International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 48(1), 53–69, 2020.
J. Yang, M. Y. P. Peng, S. Wong, W. Chong, ‘How E-learning environmental stimuli influence determinates of learning engagement in the context of COVID-19? SOR model perspective’, Frontiers in psychology, 12, 584976, 2021.
P. Sultan, H. Y. Wong, M. S. Azam, ‘How perceived communication source and food value stimulate purchase intention of organic food: An examination of the stimulus-organism-response (SOR) model’, Journal of Cleaner Production, 312, 127807, 2021.
T. Hewei, L. Youngsook, ‘Factors affecting continuous purchase intention of fashion products on social E-commerce: SOR model and the mediating effect’, Entertainment Computing, 41, 100474, 2022.
M. S. Mohamad Saleh, ‘Media and environmental non-governmental organizations (ENGOS) roles in environmental sustainability communication in Malaysia’, Discourse and Communication for Sustainable Education, 8(1), 90–101, 2017.
